Saturday 23 March 2013

Assignment 3 and DB 11 Kertesz and Cartier-Bresson versus Smith and Salgado


Assignment 3 - Group Presentation: http://agnescamalla.blogspot.ca/ 

DB 11
Research summary and contribution

Background
William Eugene Smith lived December 30th, 1918 to October 15th, 1978. He was a photojournalist who refused to compromise his professional quality; and was renown for photographs of World War two, which were very unpleasant and vivid.
After graduating from Wichita North High School n 1936, Eugene started his journey by taking photographs for; The Wichita Eagle the and Beacon, which were two local newspapers. In New York he became well known for this consistent perfectionism and tough personality. In 1939 Eugene was fired from Newsweek for distinctly objecting to the use of medium format cameras and he moved on to Life Magazine.
Eugene's ambitions took him to the front lines of World War two by the appeal of Ziff-Davis Publishing and Life. He was with the American island hopping offensive against Japan, photographing U.S Marines and Japanese prisoners of war. Unfortunately on an island called Okinawa, Eugene was hit by mortar fire; however after he recovered he continued to work at Life and made his photo essay perfect during 1947 to 1954.
In 1955 Eugene worked for Magnum photo agency where he started a documentary about Pittsburgh. The project overextended from three weeks and spanned to three years. The project was too large for showing but there were sires of book length photo essays produced over time. During 1957 to 1965 Eugene took photographs recorded jazz musicians at a Manhattan loft.
An attack by Chisso Employees near Tokyo in 1972, was an attempt to stop Eugene from the further publication of the Minamata disease. He survived the attack be it left his sight deteriorate in one eye. He lived in the city of Minamata with his wife from 1971 to 1973 and too many photographs for an essay providing the details of Minamata disease caused by a Chisso factory's discharge of heavy metals into water sources.
(Eugene took amphetamines to enable his workaholic tendencies) and the long term effect of the consumption of the drugs and alcohol created complications which took his life in 1978 via stroke.

My view on Eugene's style: 
He was very professional and obsessive with producing perfect photographs and photo essays. He risk is own life in the front lines to be able to capture the truth. He was stubborn to the extent of refusing to change his standards regardless of the consequences; example: (In 1939 Eugene was fired from Newsweek for objecting to the use of medium format cameras)


Research:

Background
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Eugene_Smith

(1945) photograph in which Marines blow up a Japanese cave on Iwo Jima.
http://masters-of-photography.com/S/smith/smith_demolition_full.html

(1944) photograph in which a wounded infant is found by an American soldier on Saipan
http://www.alderart.com/secondarypic/w%20%20eugene%20smith.htm







http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/André_Kertész 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henri_Cartier-Bresson





Andre Kertesz's photographs  are similar to Henri Cartier Bresson's in the subject of photo manipulation. They used similar techniques to create distortion effects and from viewing their photographs you can see a more artistic approach in their style.


Andre Kertesz's and Henri's photographs versus Eugene and Sebastio Salgado's photographs - Key elements that distinguish Andre's photographic style from Sebastio's photo's are abstraction, and the composition of the ratio of people. 

Abstraction: in many of Andre's and Henri's photographs for example Distortion from 1933; he manipulates the photographs and cause a distortion this distortion gives his photographs a look and feel of an abstract nature. In a press or journalistic approach at the time, such photographs would not be the norm. 
From an art point of view, in some photographs it would seem that both Andre, Henri and Sebastio's and Eugene's photographs are trying to show a bizarre twist of reality however their styles are very different. Andre and Eugene- little manipulation compared to Sebastio.

Composition of the ratio of people: in many of Andre's and Henri's photograph's the main subject seems to be some image or figure not so obvious to the eye. Even the photographs where there are groups of people in the composition their focus seems to be on the motion or actions of these people rather than their goal or numbers. In Eugene and Sebastio's photograph's the focus leads more towards a documentary approach rather than autistic approach; where the photo's capture the story of the moment that the people are expressing and a photo essay might be necessary to explain the situation.

Besides the abundance of military personnel in the photographs; these photographs also share photos with large background environments to show that the country or the place in which the event taking place is just as important.

Saturday 16 March 2013


Assignment 2: Press photography versus art photography
____________________________________
Questions:
1. The main differences and similarities between art and press photography;
2. Is it ethical and acceptable to alter art photographs? Why? Why not?
3. Is it ethical and acceptable to alter press photographs? Why? Why not?

_______________________________________________________________
Answers:
To help convey the difference of art and press photography I used the following photographs which I took.

Art Photography
Why art? 

C-Wine-2: This photograph was in the design for a promotion I did for NuYu International in 2011. The theme of the promotion was dine with wine and strawberries.

Brother at Union Station: This photograph was taken at Union Station's skywalk, Toronto of my brother in 2012. My brother was the focus of the picture however at the same time I was trying to capture the perspective, celling and walls oft e building.

__________________________________________________________
Press Photography
Why press?

Toronto Summer Fun: This is a photograph of people having fun during the summer of 2010 in the streets of  Toronto. Simply the crowds enjoying themselves which could also be titled, "the people's summer in Toronto".

Toronto from the tower: This is a photograph from the CNTower in which I  was trying to have a grand photograph of another view of toronto, a view from above. 
__________________________________________________________
The main similarities between art and press photography are the main qualities of photography itself, the rule of thirds; and invoking the viewer's emotion. By the use of the rule of thirds I am referring to the area of focus, that it's clear and simple/ easy to read but is also appealing and not boring. By invoking the viewer's emotion, this similarity of art and press photography is a quality that can been seen also in fine art. For example Paul Ruben's massacre of the innocents. Depicting the brutal sense of reality, death with the attempt to invoke emotion from the viewer.
I think it is ethical and acceptable to alter art photographs because it isn't confined to keeping realistic or factual imagery like "Journalistic or Press Photography". 
I think it isn't ethical and acceptable to alter press photography to a point. Very similar to photo Journalism I think to the point of altering the press photographs in order to improve the overall image quality is fine. However to alter the scene or composition itself or to create false imagery and false notes in a photo easy or documentation is where the line of ethnicity is crossed.

Wednesday 6 March 2013

DB 9: Photojournalism



Photojournalism

Here is the link for my research on Photo Journalism Shooting the truth at Magnum Photo Timelines.
The Cuban Revolution
http://inmotion.magnumphotos.com/essay/revolution
Cuban Revolution

Questions

- What's the role of photo journalism?
- Are there rules that photojournalists should follow? Why? Why not?
- Is the ethics of taking journalistic photos different than the ethics of writing a news story?
- What's the impact of altering press photographs? Should they be edited (at all) in postproduction?

Answers 

Cases of Photography and journalism going hand in hand is like any other form of journalism; where the truth about the situation or story of subject is being explored. By the use of photography in journalism gives the viewer or reader a visual idea of what the subject actually depicts. A photographic version of a written documentation is a valuable asset for journalism and this is were its role comes in: To convey the message or story that a journaled written or audio format is trying to convey by capturing the truth of moment visually.

Trust is the major rule which is very important and ethical. Persons in the photographs or the people who are involved in documented scenes should be able to trust that the photographer is going to use the photographs to represent factual information or the actual event.

The ethics of taking journalistic photos are very slightly different than ethics of writing a news story. Slightly because they are highly similar but are different in the sense of trust like I said above. The photographer would need the permission of the persons involved in the scene or composition in order to portray the documentation to the public. However in cases where the public is involve for example the Cuban revolution, there is no need to get permission.

In this current day it is vital to edit photographs regardless of the situation, this is for enhancing the quality or making certain important aspects of the photograph stand out from others. How ever altering the photographs can be negative if they are exaggerated too much or completely changed to alter the story itself and bring about a false image.